The Biggest Leadership Mistake During a Crisis Happens Before the Crisis
Updated: 2 days ago
What if the biggest leadership mistake during a crisis happens BEFORE the crisis even begins?

We often evaluate leaders by how effectively they respond when things go wrong. But what about how they prepare, adapt, and learn?
One of the most significant insights from my doctoral research is that effective crisis leadership doesn't begin when a crisis strikes, and it doesn't end when the crisis is over.
It is a continuous cycle.
Through my qualitative phenomenological study exploring the lived experiences of 20 executive and upper-level healthcare organizational leaders, I examined how agile leadership principles operate across the stages of crisis.
Three important findings emerged:
🔹 BEFORE THE CRISIS | Readiness
Adaptability, collaboration, and continuous learning help leaders anticipate challenges, strengthen relationships, and build organizational preparedness.
🔹 DURING THE CRISIS | Response
Responsiveness becomes especially important. Leaders must make timely decisions, communicate clearly, mobilize resources, and adapt as circumstances change.
🔹 AFTER THE CRISIS | Recovery & Renewal
Continuous learning and resilience help organizations recover, restore trust, support employees, and turn lessons learned into stronger future practices.
Here's what stood out:
Agile leadership is not simply about reacting quickly.
It's about knowing which leadership capabilities to emphasize, when to emphasize them, and how they work together.
These findings informed my proposed conceptual framework:
Although my research focused on healthcare organizational leaders, the findings raise important considerations for leaders across all industries navigating uncertainty, organizational change, and disruption.
The real test of leadership isn't based solely on how we manage a crisis, but on whether our organizations are better prepared for the next one because of what we learned from the last.
I'd love to hear from fellow leaders, researchers, and organizational professionals:
Which crisis stage do you believe organizations struggle with most: preparing for a crisis, responding to a crisis, or learning and recovering afterward?
Share your perspective in the comments. Let's advance the conversation about leadership that makes a difference.
#AgileLeadership #CrisisLeadership #LeadershipResearch #OrganizationalLeadership #OrganizationalResilience #LeadershipDevelopment #ChangeManagement #ThoughtLeadership
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About the Author
Dr. Serina Gaines is a leadership researcher, organizational strategies consultant, and founder of Leadership Palace, LLC. Dr. Gaines specializes in agile leadership and how organizations prepare for, respond to, and learn from disruption. As a doctoral graduate of Walden University, her research examined U.S. healthcare organizational leaders' lived experiences applying agile leadership principles across the pre-crisis, crisis, and post-crisis stages. Her work explores leadership adaptability, organizational resilience, crisis leadership, and the role of continuous learning in strengthening organizational readiness and response.
Through her research and professional work, Dr. Gaines seeks to translate leadership knowledge into practical strategies that support organizational effectiveness, leadership development, and positive social change.



Comments